I tried Amazon’s Bee wearable and was intrigued, but also a little creepy.

I recently had a chance to test Bee’s wearables. It’s an AI wrist gadget that Amazon acquired last year and has since updated with a number of new features.

Like other AI wearables, Bee is designed to be a kind personal assistant. It records, transcribes, and summarizes your conversations throughout the day, giving you continuous note-taking if you’re forgetful or want to be more organized in your life. Syncing with your calendar can also send you alerts and reminders about things to do throughout the day.

TechCrunch has written about Bee before, and it’s very simple. Users turn it on, put it on, sync it with the Bee mobile app, and enter basic personal information. The Bee has a built-in recorder that can be turned on and off by clicking a button on the wearable. When Bee is recording, a green light will flash. If not, the green light will turn off. Once a conversation is recorded, the app creates an easy-to-read automatic summary and transcription of the entire conversation.

Your assessment may vary depending on how provocative (or not) this conceit is. The problem for me is that I’m a privacy-oriented person. In a world where ordinary people are constantly bombarded with digital surveillance on all sides, I appreciate the opportunity to not be recorded. So the idea of ​​walking around with a listening device on your wrist 24/7 wasn’t particularly appealing.

But even I have to admit that, in the right context, Bee has a lot of potential to help organize your life.

Bee truly shines in professional interactions. If your day is full of meetings and you’re having a hard time staying on top of things, Bee could be a reasonably capable assistant.

This week, while on a work-related call, I activated Bee after receiving confirmation that I could record the meeting. The app then faithfully returned a summary of the conversation, breaking down each part of the conversation in an easy-to-understand way so I could review it later without having to listen to the entire conversation again. While this was definitely helpful, it’s worth noting that this isn’t significantly different from what other transcription services like Otter and Granola offer, which also offer transcriptions and auto-generated summaries.

That being said, I can also imagine a situation where a professional who has to move between various meetings throughout the day could be well served by this device. You can also keep Bee running throughout the day and review the conversation summary later for any questions.

While Bee does a relatively good job of summarizing conversations, the actual transcript provided by the wearable can be a little confusing. Previous reviewers have pointed out that Bee doesn’t always know who’s speaking, so you usually have to manually enter the names of other speakers. During the conversation, I noticed that certain sections of the chat were left out. It wasn’t much, but it wasn’t a complete explanation of everything that was said.

I also took the Bee to movie nights twice a week with friends and left it running all night. Given the fact that we were watching Reservoir Dogs, I was mildly concerned that the wearable might mistake all the vile carnage for real-life bloodshed and trigger some kind of internal alarm. But Bee basically knew what was going on. The wearable knew we were watching a movie, and in a summary of what happened next, the wearable labeled the conversation “Analysis of Tarantino Movie Scenes.”

While Bee is showing early promise as a professional tool, you don’t want it to record your private life. Oddly enough, Bee has been primarily marketed as a product for personal use. To be happy with that, you have to be happy that Bee has access to a large part of your life, both offline and digital.

In fact, Bee requires extensive mobile permissions to function properly, including access to your location, photos, phone contacts, calendar, and mobile notifications. You can also share your health data if for some reason you want to know your sleep patterns or resting heart rate.

A large amount of data collected by Bee is stored in the cloud, which is also a concern for digital privacy enthusiasts. In a message to technology YouTuber Becca Farsace, Bee appears to have released a demo of the device that works entirely locally. If the company could produce such a device, I would be very impressed and might consider purchasing one. That said, Amazon has not provided any updates regarding these plans.

As for Bee’s digital privacy protection, the company says it offers encryption to protect user data both at rest and in transit. The company says in its privacy policy that it “has implemented technical and organizational security measures designed to protect the security of any personal information” it processes. Bee also claims to have undergone “rigorous third-party security audits” and conducts continuous security monitoring. While this all sounds very good, it’s worth noting that Amazon, like many large technology companies, is subject to data security issues from time to time (not surprising for a company that manages such a global cloud environment, but still).

In short, the Bee is an interesting piece of hardware that, with some time and fine-tuning, could lead to promising professional applications. However, as a digital assistant for your personal life, it may be a little too intrusive for some users.