Pontiac, Michigan (AP) – Michigan judge who chaired Parent’s First Belief In shootings at US schools, prosecutors strongly suggested on Friday that agreements should be made clear with two important trial witnesses.
However, Judge Cheryl Matthews has not yet decided whether Jennifer and James Crumbley should receive a new trial as a result.
Matthews heard the argument from James Crumbleley’s appeals lawyer. Similar pitch From his wife’s lawyer. Crumbie was separately convicted of involuntary manslaughter last year in the deaths of four students killed by her son. Oxford High School in 2021.
They were accused of negligence and did not predict that Ethan Crumby was a risk to the school.
The post-trial appeals mainly focus on the failure of Oakland County prosecutors to grant a counsel agreement made with two school officials. Nick Ejacque and Sean Hopkins were promised that statements to investigators after the shooting would not be used against them. They were not charged.
Ejak and Hopkins were important trial witnesses. They met Crumbie and his son before the shooting and agreed that the boy could remain at school despite the falling blood, a gun and a creepy picture of desperate words.
Ejak joked that it was heavy, but no one checked the gun with a 15-year-old backpack. Ejacques and Hopkins told the ju decree that meeting with their parents was short and they didn’t want to bring him home.
The parents’ lawyers allege that failure to disclose pre-trial agreements violated the basic rules of the criminal justice system. Ejacques and Hopkins may have been cross-examined about the transaction, they say, and the ju-degree may have used the information in assessing their reliability.
The judge said the prosecutor “probably” violated the rules. Matthews said decisions on whether a new exam is needed will be weeks away.
James Crumbly’s lawyer, Alona Sharon, has admitted that shooting at an Oxford school is “courage” for the community.
“But our rules cannot bend to emotions,” Sharon told the judge. “If that’s the case, our judicial system has no integrity, and the rules have no meaning. The constitution has no meaning.
Prosecutor Mark Keyst once again defended his office’s decision not to disclose the agreement before trial, saying it wasn’t necessary. He said they were not full immunity, but limited deals with Ejacques and Hopkins.
Keast said the ju umpire heard a lot of evidence about James Crumble’s negligence before the shooting, and information that it “has nothing to do with Ejacques or Hopkins.”
Crumble serves a 10-year prison term. Ethan Crumby is now 18 years old Serves life sentence After pleading guilty to murder or other crimes.
Source link
